Miss SNPJ Titleholders
| Year of Title | Name | Lodge |
| 1957 | Marlynn Turki | Lodge 138, Strabane, PA |
| 1958 | Janet Snyder | Lodge 36, Willock, PA |
| 1959 | Marie Tome | Lodge 8, South Chicago, IL |
| 1960 | Nancy Sleber | Lodge 87, Herminie, PA |
| 1961 | Sandra Ogrin | Lodge 14, Waukegan, IL |
| 1962 | Gail Nachtigal | Lodge 604, Cleveland, OH |
| 1963 | Ruth Butkovich | Lodge 270, Lyons, IL |
| 1964 | Karen Solomon | Lodge 87, Herminie, PA |
| 1965 | Elaine Kvartich | Lodge 6, Sygan, PA |
| 1966 | Nancy Skiba | Lodge 615, Los Angeles, CA |
| 1967 | Linda Serro | Lodge 87, Herminie, PA |
| 1968 | Barbara Turkovich | Lodge 137, Cleveland, OH |
| 1969 | Jane Gregorin | Lodge 14, Waukegan, IL |
| 1970 | Patricia Hlebak | Lodge 604, Cleveland, OH |
| 1971 | Carol Bokal | Lodge 142, Cleveland, OH |
| 1972 | Denise Lamm | Lodge 566, Euclid, OH |
| 1973 | Linda Roginski | Lodge 33, Ambridge, PA |
| 1974 | Michelle Volk | Lodge 117, Yukon, PA |
| 1975 | Judy Pintar | Lodge 6, Sygan, PA |
| 1976 | Joyce Braddock | Lodge 158, Euclid, OH |
| 1977 | Cheri Gottke | Lodge 26, Cleveland, OH |
| 1978 | Kathy Hlad | Lodge 576, Cleveland, OH |
| 1979 | Carol Morvetz | Lodge 87, Herminie, PA |
| 1980 | Valerie Stodolsky | Lodge 87, Herminie, PA |
| 1981 | Justina Dabrowski | Lodge 449, Cicero, IL |
| 1982 | Tracey Anderson | Lodge 677, Detroit, MI |
| 1983 | Karen Kovach | Lodge 142, Cleveland, OH |
| 1984 | Toni Trontel | Lodge 262, Sharon, PA |
| 1985 | Jackie Morvetz | Lodge 87, Herminie, PA |
| 1986 | Kathy Roginski | Lodge 33, Ambridge, PA |
| 1987 | Mary Ann Racic | Lodge 723, Fontana, CA |
| 1988 | Gretchen Buday | Lodge 153, Youngstown, OH |
| 1989 | Teresa Mlakar | Lodge 723, Fontana, CA |
| 1990 | Lisa Vidergar | Lodge 723, Fontana, CA |
| 1991 | Melissa Lawrence | Lodge 138, Strabane, PA |
| 1992 | Anna Marie Klepec | Lodge 643, Girard, OH |
| 1993 | Stacey Apanaites | Lodge 158, Euclid, OH |
| 1994 | Deirdre Kocjan | Lodge 643, Girard, OH |
| 1995 | Jennifer Skrajner | Lodge 142, Cleveland, OH |
| 1996 | Allison Engel | Lodge 138, Strabane, PA |
| 1997 | Elizabeth Buchner | Lodge 576, Cleveland, OH |
| (1) 1999 | Kelli Blair | Lodge 784, South Charleston, WV |
| 2000 | Christine Wojtila | Lodge 158, Euclid, OH |
| 2001 | Kandace Kocjan | Lodge 643, Girard, OH |
| 2002 | Carissa Pabian | Lodge 138, Strabane, PA |
| 2003 | Amanda Fordyce | Lodge 5, Cleveland, OH |
| 2004 | Courtney Pabian | Lodge 138, Strabane, PA |
| 2005 | Caralynn Fejka | Lodge 153, Youngstown, OH |
| 2006 | Shannon Fetcko | Lodge 138, Strabane, PA |
| 2007 | Darcy Brand | Lodge 6, Sygan, PA |
| 2008 | Kristy Zivkovich | Lodge 158, Euclid, OH |
| 2009 | Brittney Zemko | Lodge 643, Girard, OH |
| 2010 | Kara Maruszak | Lodge 53, Cleveland, OH |
| 2011 | Selina Progar | Lodge 138, Strabane, PA |
| 2012 | Danielle Brand | Lodge 6, Sygan, PA |
| 2013 | Kristen Cushman | Lodge 138, Strabane, PA |
| 2014 | Ashley Russ | Lodge 158, Euclid, OH |
| 2015 | Nicole Vehar | Lodge 138, Strabane, PA |
| 2016 | Julie Rockwell | Lodge 138, Strabane, PA |
| 2017 | Elizabeth Hartman | Lodge 138, Strabane, PA |
| 2018 | Lauren Sebusch | Lodge 576, Cleveland, OH |
| 2019 | Elizabeth Smrdel | Lodge 158, Euclid, OH |
| 2020 | Daniella Volpe | Lodge 158, Euclid, OH |
| (2) 2023 | Madison Sinan | Lodge 782, Glenshaw, PA |
| 2024 | Morgan Sinan | Lodge 782, Glenshaw, PA |
| 2025 | Erin Lawrence | Lodge 138, Strabane, PA |
(1) No Miss SNPJ title was awarded for 1998. The Miss SNPJ Pageant was moved from National SNPJ Days weekend to Slovenefest weekend in 1998, and the winner of the Miss SNPJ title during the 1998 pageant is recognized as Miss SNPJ 1999.
(2) Miss SNPJ Pageants were not held in 2020 or 2021 due to the Covid-19 pandemic.
